| The Best Paper of them All (47 Votes) |
| Paper Mario N64 |
29.79% JO13, junninx, lemmingscanfly, Luigi1er, Mosky Juarez, Mrhomelesshobo, pieordie1, RobiNERD, Sir_Waddle100, Thamz, Trader, WarioWario128, 2 Guests |
14 |
29.79% |
| Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door |
42.55% bustacrunk, Crashing Thunder, CyberMario, Cyborg, David, Flame8765, Greave, henry242, lezg_g, Mario135, Mariohacker14, MarioPower55, Mogsiah, Poudink, Waschpenner, wurmi32LP, 4 Guests |
20 |
42.55% |
| Super Paper Mario |
25.53% 8_BitKing, BaconBoy, BlackStone187, FireMario74, GunnyDawg, Kaze, LuigiXHero, Mr Infinite, MWeegee, Quasmok, supermariosan100, 1 Guest |
12 |
25.53% |
| Paper Mario: Sticker Star |
2.13% Jesse |
1 |
2.13% |
